HomerDough's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Sherbert the Cat 3-1]

Me confused

Improve
Elaborate on the plot. Make it much longer. Way shorter than your other Sherbert flashes. Also add some violence. hardly any violence.

Pretty bad considering your skill with flash. I didn't know what was going on.

3/5
Review Request Club

Jonimator responds:

As i said before this is short because i split the 3rd sherbert into 2 parts. And if it makes you happy there'll ve violence in the 2nd part. Sorry to disapoint you.
Thanks for the review.

[The Snowball Cartoon]

Cool

Improve
Npt really a lot but there could be a sound when the snowball makes contac (like a splat or something)

Cool flash (nice preloader)

4/5
Review Request Club

Jimtopia responds:

Yeah, well I wanted to make sure the music could be heard, but thx for ur suggestion.

[Jimtopia Changes]

Cool

Improve
the graphics sucked ass but you could've made it at least 3d-looking. Also the animation tweening was pretty bad. Some animation as good like the background but thats about it. Otherwise it was real funny

3/5
Review Request Club

Jimtopia responds:

Ah, well, thx for the 7. I'm glad you thought it was funny.

[Sherbert the Cat 2]

Cool Flash

Improve
Some of the animation was off like the mouses going throuh the desk and stuff like that. But thats about it

The graphics were pretty good. The music was really into the whole flash so good selection. The movie was funny like when Sherbert was panting n the wall.

Great job

4/5
Review Request Club

Jonimator responds:

Thanks for reviewing! I will make sure in Sherbert 3, nothing goes through anything. I just watched it after reading this and your right. I'm glad you liked it. Once again thanks for the review.

[A Kingly Melody]

Damn good

The graphics were damn good. The animation wasn't all that bad. The timing of the events were pretty damn good. The music was very uplifting and "happy". No violence but because its a "happy" film, you don't need any. You can add some humor though, I don't know put SBC tripping at some point. Get a chuckle out of the audience. it was a great movie altogether.

Review Request Club

MetalDart responds:

Ugh, you've reviewed all my flashes, it's like I have an e-stalker. D:

Also, I love how you critique my flashes on that stuff when all you make is tutorials. Not an insult, I'm just saying try giving us animators a break every once in a while. I know you gave this a positive review, but if I only responded to one of your reviews, I think you'd have a greater chance for reading it.

Thanks for the positive review man, it means a lot.

<3